Another homework question that comes up a lot for students of all ages is the question of parent help. The student may be too dependent on parent help, the student may resist parent help, or it all may be a very messy process of some help, some nagging, some yelling, and some crying (on all sides!). To answer this question, we have to get back to the purpose of the homework and think about the type of help we provide.
If the purpose of the homework is preparation for class (usually this is reading or researching), then creating a situation where the child is doing that preparation effectively is the most helpful thing you can do. Creating the time for the work or possibly helping them locate audio books or software to support this might be the best way to assist.
If the purpose of the homework is practice or a final project, then the child really needs to be able to do it without your help (aside from creating the time and space for them to complete the work). If the child cannot complete this work on his/her own, then the teacher needs to know so they can address the needs in class. If this is a chronic issue, then we may need to meet about providing the child with the proper plan and support for moving forward in that subject. The most effective assistance will be offering supplies, time, and space.
The type of help we give is very important. The most important rule of help to remember is that every time you help, you send the message that “you cannot do this on your own.” This is an okay message to send when it’s true and you want to send this message. Unfortunately, we often send this message when we don’t intend to and we create helpless dependence on us, an aversion to failure/risk, and lower self-confidence.
Dr. Montessori said the child’s perennial request is “help me do it by myself.” Giving feedback, editing a paper, or looking over a math sheet might be fine if you challenge the child to think through what they already know. “You might re-read the first paragraph and look for appropriate capitalization.” Or “You didn’t show your work on #9. Doesn’t your teacher require you to show your work?” This is empowering the child to develop good habits. Sitting down to the computer to edit their paper or cutting out their science fair paragraphs is not empowering them… in fact it undercuts their growth. The daily grind of hard work, making mistakes, and receiving feedback is developing cognitive and emotional habits they need for life.
Many kids won’t want their parents’ help. This is fine too and displays a healthy sense of independence. Whether they feel vulnerable about the paper they wrote or they are just separating from their parents a bit, this is a healthy step for them to take. It shows great maturity and executive function skills if they can do their homework and turn it in without parent involvement — in fact this should be every parents’ goal before senior year.
If you have concerns about your child’s follow-through, you should partner with the teachers, letting the teachers know that you are hands-off and asking them to let you know if you should be more directive or if you should support them with any structure or discipline at home. Your relationship will be better without the added conflict, and your child will develop more self-confidence, organizational skills, and independence necessary for college and life beyond!